Stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eye Liner Review

The first few times I tried the Stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eye Liner on my waterline, my eyes would not stop tearing! I still have no idea what caused it, but luckily I gave it a second chance (the things we do for beauty) a few days later because I loved the pigmentation and feel of the liners, and thankfully it didn’t happen again. Some of these have even become my most used liners.

Stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eyeliner Review and Swatches

Swatches from top-bottom:

Angelfish- Rose Gold/Champagne Shimmer

Starfish- Olive Green/Gold Shimmer

Black Amethyst- Matte Black Purple

Damsel- Matte Black Brown

Midnight Blue- Matte Deep Navy

Stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eye Liner

As you can see from the swacthes, most of these are super-pigmented, aside from Midnight Blue, which was a bit of a disappointment. They all apply smoothly, don’t drag at the skin, don’t smudge and last all day, although I do find the matte shades apply more smoothly than the shimmer shades. My favourite has got to be Damsel to line my waterline, and Angelfish in the inner corners of my eyes to brighten the area.

Stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eyeliner Review and Swatches

Have you tried any of the Stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eye Liners?

Related Posts

None found

This Post Has 53 Comments

    1. admin

      Oh I really love Stila products, so many goodies!

  1. Caroline

    I love the look of Starfish, such a pretty colour! Stila do some fantastic eye products. Have you tried their Glitter & Glow Liquid Eyeshadows? xx

    1. admin

      I haven’t, but I have heard they are amazing!

  2. Jade Wilson

    I LOVE the pinky shade!!! Thank you for a brilliant post

    1. admin

      Thanks for reading Jade! It is such a wonderful colour!

  3. Lady Writes

    If these really don’t budge then I need them in my life – just maybe not the blue! x

    1. admin

      Yes, not the blue definitely! The others are lovely though!

  4. Adrienne

    I don’t think I have tried these but I love the lilac/nude shade! x

    1. admin

      It is so lovely to highlight the inner corner of the eye!

  5. Bernadette Rihana

    Stila have definitely aced the game when it comes to making long-lasting eyeliners! I’ve tried their liquid stay all day eyeliner and oh my did it last, so I definitely need to try these ones out. I usually avoid stick eyeliners because they don’t last but these look amazing!

    1. admin

      I still haven’t tried their liquid one, even though it has been on my wishlist for ages!

    1. admin

      It is so pretty Shelley!

  6. Alice Spake

    I’ve never used much from Stila before but I really like the sound of the black liner xx

    1. admin

      It is so pigmented and long lasting!

    1. admin

      It is so pretty! It works so well to brighten the eye area!

  7. bekylou

    I love the look of midnight – I’m getting into experimenting more and it looks like such an interesting colour

    1. admin

      It is, but unfortunately the pigmentation is just not there!

  8. Erin

    I love the formula of these! I have a few already and they are beautiful 🙂

    Erin || MakeErinOver

  9. Robyn

    I have heard great things about this and now I really want to try it!! xx

    1. admin

      You definitely should if you can!

  10. Emma

    I love that rose gold shimmer!! It looks gorgeous and perfect for a date night x

    1. admin

      It’s so pretty to highlight the inner corner!

  11. Maisie

    I haven’t tried any of these but they are all such gorgeous shades! x

    1. admin

      They are so pretty, I love them!

  12. R Fourie

    The Michelle Ori Paris eye liners are very pigmented and soft. One of my favourite brands. I do not own any Stila ones.

    1. admin

      I haven’t tried those Reonette, but will definitely check them out now! Thank you!

  13. Megan McCoig

    I don’t wear liner like these enough because I am so scared of them smudging or not lasting long. These sound like something I need to try! X

    1. admin

      They don’t smudge which I love. They work so well on the waterline!

  14. Gemma

    Ahh I haven’t tried these but they look stunning! I love Stila so I will have to get myself one x

    1. admin

      It’s such a lovely brand, and these are super pretty!

  15. Rosie

    I usually only use liquid liners on myself but these definitely look worth a go! Love them!

    1. admin

      They are super pretty! Definitely worth a try!

  16. Terri Heckley

    Oh that rose gold shade is calling my name, so stunning!

    1. admin

      It is pretty! Basically the liner version of Stila Kitten!

  17. Sarah

    I’m more of a felt tip eyeliner person but i love Black Amethyst,

    1. admin

      It is such a pretty shade!

  18. candice

    They actually look super pigmented! Haven’t tried their liners before.

    Candice | Beauty Candy Loves

    1. admin

      You definitely should try Candice. They are lovely!

  19. Sal UmmBaby

    Ooh I will be swatching Damsel next time I visit the stand. I love a good brown pencil liner xxx

    1. admin

      Yup it is amazing! So matte and so dark!

  20. Issybellefox

    I really love how pigmented these are, I like the shades too they’re subtle yet striking x

    1. admin

      Yup and the colours are so unusual! They are really pretty!

  21. leanne page

    I haven’t tried these. They sound great though. I will defo check them out. I love the look of anglefish, i don’t have a shade like that in my collection either xx

    1. admin

      It’s so pretty for the inner corner, it is basically Stila Kitten in a liner!

  22. Alice Fairweather

    I must prefer a pencil style eyeliner over a liquid, I might have to try these! x

    1. admin

      Me too! These are really lovely, and retractable!

  23. Beautylymin

    Starfish is my kind of colour! I don’t really use regular liners very much – just liquid liners! xx


Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.