The first few times I tried the Stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eye Liner on my waterline, my eyes would not stop tearing! I still have no idea what caused it, but luckily I gave it a second chance (the things we do for beauty) a few days later because I loved the pigmentation and feel of the liners, and thankfully it didn't happen again. Some of these have even become my most used liners. Swatches from top-bottom: Angelfish- Rose Gold/Champagne Shimmer Starfish- Olive Green/Gold Shimmer Black Amethyst- Matte Black Purple Damsel- Matte Black Brown Midnight Blue- Matte Deep Navy As…